page title img


Tony ′s Pizzeria

About Us


Our History

Tony’s Pizza was established in a small shop located at 311 Cleveland Drive in North Cheektowaga, NY 14225 in 1967 by Tony himself! By focusing on providing the most delicious food, made with the highest quality ingredients, serving it up with a courteous staff, all while providing the customer with the best overall value; the establishment quickly became a local must-have. Soon it was apparent that Tony’s had become North Cheektowaga’s favorite pizzeria, and it was necessary to move our operation to a larger location, to meet the growing demand of our great community.

In 1979 Tony’s Pizza moved to 3680 Harlem Road North Cheektowaga, NY 14215 just a short trip up the road from the original location. Instantly, moving onto a busier street brought even more customers, and word of the high quality ingredients being used, the amazing, authentic recipes, and the great service traveled quickly by word of mouth. Soon, we saw more and more new faces, until it was not an uncommon sight to see the parking lot full and lots of new customers discovering their new favorite North Cheektowaga pizzeria. Today, those fine traditions still ring true. In 1999 we opened our second location at 2770 Union Road Cheektowaga, NY 14227 as a full service restaurant. We are into our 3rd generation family ownership. Please stop by and see Tony, Marc, Greg and Zac.

Cheektowaga Pizzeia - Tony's Pizza

Just take a look at our pizza menu: We have something for everyone! From our amazing Veggie Pizza, topped with locally grown, fresh Spanish onions, black olives, Romano cheese and parsley all baked to perfection on a garlic butter base; to our Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza, bringing you the great taste of a classic bacon cheeseburger on a pizza dough base of ketchup and mustard, loaded with beef, cheddar, Monterey jack, and mozzarella cheese. Of course, don’t forget the bacon. Or, go for a Pizza All the Way, loaded with cheese, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, hot peppers, and our own homemade sausage! Also, speaking of cheese, did you know that we only use 100% real dairy cheese? No unnecessary preservatives or additives, and it’s made locally. In fact, most of our ingredients come from local sources, including some fresh, locally grown produce. Couple all of this with our secret pizza sauce recipe, and you can expect nothing short of perfection coming out of our old-style brick ovens!

Looking for some Buffalo chicken wings? Maybe some appetizers? Our fryers are ready to cook up exactly what you crave! We’ve got everything, from pizza logs to chicken dinners. Of course, in true Buffalo fashion, we serve a fantastic fish fry every Friday, made with fresh, hand-breaded haddock. The usual suspects are all here as well: french fries, onion rings, mozzarella sticks, chicken fingers, boneless chicken bites, and even sweet treats like fried dough and carnival style funnel cake fries! One thing is for sure, if you’ve got a craving for some delicious fried food, you can feel free to give in and indulge because we’ve got what you’re looking for.

What Buffalo / WNY Pizzeria would be complete without serving up some excellent submarine style sandwiches!? Here at Tony’s Pizzeria, we continue our traditions and keep it local, using only fresh Costanzo’s brand sub and sandwich rolls. And guess what else? They’re delivered fresh daily. We’ve got a ton of specialty subs from our T-Bomb (need menu description), to our belly busting stinger sub, featuring 100% rib-eye steak, crispy fried chicken fingers, cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Now that’s a sandwich! We also feature wraps, tacos, burritos, and an assortment of salads ranging from Mediterranean chicken salads, taco salads, or even our classic Antipasto salad. If you’re looking for something quick on the go, Tony’s subs and wraps are a sure thing. Always be sure to ask about our sub of the month, as we offer a specific sub at a discounted price every month!

No matter what you’re looking for when it comes to authentic Buffalo pizzeria food, Tony’s Pizza has you covered. We offer specials like our Monday night pizza special, where a large cheese and one item pizza is offered at an exceptionally low price! Or, stop in on a Tuesday and enjoy $1.00 off of any whole sub in the place. Fridays, we bring out our traditional WNY fish fry, loaded with two large pieces of fish, homemade coleslaw, potato salad, french fries, lemon and tartar sauce.. all for one low price. Rounding out the week, Saturdays bring a special discounted price on sheet pizzas. Of course, we also have our everyday specials where you can find anything from a sheet pizza and 50 wings, to a small pizza and ten wings. We even have specials including boneless chicken wings! Be sure to check out our extensive menu for a look at all of our specials. You won’t be disappointed!

For nearly 50 years, Tony’s pizza has provided the fine people of Cheektowaga NY with delicious food, and we’d like thank each and every one of you for your loyal patronage. We have joined your family at the dinner table and shared many great laughs and good times at your graduation parties, birthday parties, and other celebrations. Don’t forget, we also offer catering service for your events in Buffalo and WNY, so be sure to call for more information if you’re interested. So, next time you’re in the mood for a traditional, Buffalo style pizzeria experience, look no further than Tony’s Pizza Cheektowaga, NY. We hope to see you soon!