Discover Cheektowaga’s
Hidden Gem

Tony’s Pizza is a beloved pizza and sub shop located in Cheektowaga, NY. Established in 1967, we have been serving up delicious, handcrafted pizzas, mouthwatering subs, and a variety of other tasty menu items for over five decades.

At Tony’s Pizza, we take great pride in using only the freshest ingredients to ensure every bite is packed with flavor. Our commitment to quality, along with our friendly service, has earned us a reputation as a go-to destination for authentic and satisfying meals.

Our History

At Tony’s Pizza, our story began in 1967 when our founder, Tony, opened our first location at 311 Cleveland Drive. Thanks to our commitment to using only high-quality ingredients and providing exceptional customer service, we quickly became a Cheektowaga favorite. As demand grew, we moved to a bigger location at 3680 Harlem Road in 1979, which helped us attract even more loyal customers. In 2018, we opened our second location in Sandborn to better serve our community. Now, with three generations of family ownership, we continue to offer our delicious Buffalo-style pizzas, subs, and other mouth-watering menu items at both of our locations.



Become a part of our legacy.

Join Our Team

Unmatched Pizza Perfection

Authentic Buffalo Flavors

Experience the true taste of Buffalo with our locally sourced ingredients and secret pizza sauce recipe, all cooked to perfection in our old-style brick ovens.

Family-Owned Tradition

For nearly 60 years, Tony’s Pizza has been a beloved Cheektowaga pizzeria, passed down through three generations of family ownership, making each visit feel like dining with family.

Something for Everyone

From classic Buffalo-style pizzas and wings to mouth-watering subs, wraps, and salads, we offer something for everyone, ensuring a delicious experience with every bite.

Exceptional Value

At Tony’s Pizza, we take pride in providing the best overall value to our customers through generous portions, daily specials, and a commitment to using only high-quality ingredients.

Testimonials That’ll Make Your Mouth Water!

Ready to experience the tantalizing flavors & rich history of Tony’s Pizza for yourself? Order now & join the countless satisfied customers who have made Tony’s their go-to pizzeria!

Tony's Pizza
3680 Harlem Road
Cheektowaga, NY 14215

Phone: 716-833-1700

Business Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 11:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Friday - Saturday: 11:00 AM - 1:00 AM
Sunday: 11:00 AM - 12:00 AM

Get Directions!

Order Online!

Follow Us On Facebook

Discover Cheektowaga’sHidden Gem